Comparisons
Plain, sourced comparisons from the brands I actually wear.
Blundstone vs Oliver vs Mongrel on wet sites
Zip-side steel caps, compared from official maker pages, plus recollection from wet civil work.
Slip-on steel-cap boots for wide feet
Elastic-side examples from the same three brands, with official width claims kept separate from a wide-profile cap.
Zip-side vs elastic-side steel-cap boots
What the makers say the two closures are for, without pretending the zip is a waterproofing test.